Abercrombie vs Old Navy Petite | Petite Pick

As of the latest catalog refresh, Petite Pick indexes 179 petite items at Abercrombie and 1,675 at Old Navy. Average current price is $125 at Abercrombie versus $20 at Old Navy; 3% of Abercrombie petite items are on sale versus 100% at Old Navy.

Abercrombie carries 179 petite items across 5 categories (top: Dresses (137), Skirts (18), Coats (18)). Old Navy carries 1,675 across 9 categories (top: Tops (536), Activewear (404), Sweaters (241)). Average current prices are $125 and $20 respectively.

Retailers on this page

Retailer	Items	Avg price	From	On sale
Nordstrom	3,179	$190	$17	36%
Macy's	2,737	$77	$5	67%
Old Navy	1,675	$20	$3	100%
ASOS	1,443	$75	$12	29%
Talbots	1,302	$109	$30	0%

Abercrombie vs Old Navy Petite — Side-by-Side Comparison (1,854)

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Faux Shearling Long Coat - Light Brown

New New!

Faux Shearling Long Coat

$240

00/XXS

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

New

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Snug Long-Sleeve Boatneck T-Shirt

40% OFF

New

Snug Long-Sleeve Boatneck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.8 (140) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S

Mock Neck Cable Mini Sweater Dress - Red

New New!

Mock Neck Cable Mini Sweater Dress

$110

2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday vacation classic

Wool-Blend Funnel Neck Long Coat - Brown

Wool-Blend Funnel Neck Long Coat

$250

4 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Flannel Pajama Pants

$18 $30

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Faux Fur Long Coat - Brown

New New!

Faux Fur Long Coat

$240

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Fine Wool-Blend Draped Maxi Dress - Cream

New New!

Fine Wool-Blend Draped Maxi Dress

$130

4 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

100% Cotton A&F Dylan Bra-Free Midi Dress - Black

New New!

100% Cotton A&F Dylan Bra-Free Midi Dress

$140

2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$18 $30

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

work everyday vacation

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$18 $30

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday work vacation

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday vacation classic

Lace-Trim Velvet Midi Dress - Black

New New!

Lace-Trim Velvet Midi Dress

$150

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching Best Seller

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 17 colors

20/XXL

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

40% OFF

Oversized Button-Down Boyfriend Shirt

$24 $40

4.6 (13454) 9 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

everyday work vacation

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

Best Seller

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 7 colors

20/XXL

everyday active loungewear

A&F Madeline Mini Sweater Dress - Deep Navy

A&F Madeline Mini Sweater Dress

$95

6 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

Best Seller

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday active loungewear

Bra-Free Beaded Mesh Mini Dress - Black

New New!

Bra-Free Beaded Mesh Mini Dress

$140

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

Best Seller

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday active loungewear

Smocked Dipped-Waist Crepe Mini Dress - Red Plaid

New New!

Smocked Dipped-Waist Crepe Mini Dress

$90

2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Lace-Trim Velvet Mock Neck Mini Dress - Black

New New!

Lace-Trim Velvet Mock Neck Mini Dress

$90

2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

New

Flannel Pajama Pants

$18 $30

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Mock Neck Maxi Dress - Dark Brown

Mock Neck Maxi Dress

$110

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 15 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Full-Zip Hoodie Sweatshirt

$27 $45

4.7 (4309) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Bra-Free Lace-Trim Mini Dress - Pink

New New!

Bra-Free Lace-Trim Mini Dress

$100

3 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

Best Seller

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

everyday loungewear active

Flannel Pajama Pants

40% OFF

New

Flannel Pajama Pants

$15 $25

4.6 (800) 16 colors

16/XL 18/XXL 20/XXL

Funnel-Neck Core Puffer Jacket

40% OFF

Funnel-Neck Core Puffer Jacket

$36 $60

4.8 (39) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

First-Layer Ribbed Scoop-Neck Tank Top

40% OFF

First-Layer Ribbed Scoop-Neck Tank Top

$8 $13

4.6 (10679) 2 colors

0/XS

everyday active loungewear

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

everyday loungewear active

Funnel-Neck Core Puffer Jacket

40% OFF

Funnel-Neck Core Puffer Jacket

$36 $60

4.8 (39) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Merino Wool-Blend Slash Neck Mini Sweater Dress - Oatmeal

New New!

Merino Wool-Blend Slash Neck Mini Sweater Dress

$100

3 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

40% OFF

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

$18 $30

4.6 (215) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Wool-Blend Tailored Topcoat - Black

Wool-Blend Tailored Topcoat

$230

3 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

40% OFF

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

$18 $30

4.6 (215) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat - Light Brown Houndstooth

A&F Carrie Wool-Blend Trench Coat

$250

7 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

everyday active sporty

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

40% OFF

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

$18 $30

4.6 (215) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Belted Denim Jumpsuit - Brown

Belted Denim Jumpsuit

$140

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

40% OFF

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

$18 $30

4.6 (215) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Wool-Blend Tailored Topcoat - Black

Wool-Blend Tailored Topcoat

$230

3 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted SoComfy Jogger Sweatpants

$22 $37

4.7 (6363) 9 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

40% OFF

Performance Fleece Funnel Neck Pullover

$18 $30

4.6 (215) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

«
1
2
3
…
26
»

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Abercrombie or Old Navy have more petite items?: Old Navy currently has more, with 1,675 petite items versus 179.
Which is cheaper on average, Abercrombie or Old Navy?: Average current prices are $125 at Abercrombie and $20 at Old Navy.
Which retailer has more petite items on sale?: Abercrombie has 3% of its petite items on sale, versus 100% at Old Navy.
What sizes do Abercrombie and Old Navy carry in petite?: Both retailers offer petite sizing roughly from 00/XXS to 20/XXL depending on the item.
How often is this comparison updated?: Counts and prices on this page are recomputed from the live catalog on each request; the underlying catalog refreshes daily.