J.Crew vs Old Navy Petite | Petite Pick

As of the latest catalog refresh, Petite Pick indexes 257 petite items at J.Crew and 1,675 at Old Navy. Average current price is $176 at J.Crew versus $20 at Old Navy; 9% of J.Crew petite items are on sale versus 100% at Old Navy.

J.Crew carries 257 petite items across 8 categories (top: Pants (114), Jeans (39), Dresses (36)). Old Navy carries 1,675 across 9 categories (top: Tops (536), Activewear (404), Sweaters (241)). Average current prices are $176 and $20 respectively.

Retailers on this page

Retailer	Items	Avg price	From	On sale
Nordstrom	3,179	$190	$17	36%
Macy's	2,737	$77	$5	67%
Old Navy	1,675	$20	$3	100%
ASOS	1,443	$75	$12	29%
Talbots	1,302	$109	$30	0%

J.Crew vs Old Navy Petite — Side-by-Side Comparison (1,932)

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

40% OFF

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

$33 $55

4.6 (9166) 10 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

46% OFF

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

$8 $15

4.6 (24797) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

everyday active classic

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

85% OFF

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

$9 $60

4.6 (9166) 10 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 16/XL +1

everyday classic bohemian

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

46% OFF

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

$8 $15

4.6 (24797) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

everyday loungewear active

Petite long-sleeve mini shirt-dress in denim - Other

Petite long-sleeve mini shirt-dress in denim

$178

4.9 (23)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

40% OFF

High-Waisted OG Loose Jeans

$27 $45

4.6 (9166) 10 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

46% OFF

EveryWear V-Neck T-Shirt

$8 $15

4.6 (24797) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday classic minimalist

SoSoft Mock-Neck Shaker Sweater

40% OFF

SoSoft Mock-Neck Shaker Sweater

$27 $45

4.6 (270) 8 colors

20/XXL

Petite Ophelia long-sleeve dress in plaid poplin - Other

Petite Ophelia long-sleeve dress in plaid poplin

$178

5.0 (1)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

$15 $25

3.4 (10) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

Extra High-Waisted Super Wide-Leg Jeans

40% OFF

Extra High-Waisted Super Wide-Leg Jeans

$33 $55

4.6 (1561) 3 colors

4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L 16/XL 18/XXL

everyday classic modern

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$21 $35

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Ophelia long-sleeve dress in daisy-print viscose twill - Other

Petite Ophelia long-sleeve dress in daisy-print viscose twill

$198

5.0 (2)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

$15 $25

3.4 (10) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$24 $40

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Esme button-up shirt in striped cupro blend - Other

Petite Esme button-up shirt in striped cupro blend

$128

4.7 (117)

12/L

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

$15 $25

3.4 (10) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$24 $40

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in lightspun wool blend - Other

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in lightspun wool blend

$148

4.8 (31) 2 colors

0/XS

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in lightspun wool blend - Other

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in lightspun wool blend

$148

4.8 (31) 2 colors

4/S 6/S 10/M

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

40% OFF

Family Matching New

Flannel Pajama Joggers for Women

$15 $25

3.4 (10) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +3

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$21 $35

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Fairfax skirt in houndstooth wool with lace - Other

Petite Fairfax skirt in houndstooth wool with lace

$178

4.9 (50)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

40% OFF

Best Seller

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

$33 $55

4.6 (2803) 3 colors

0/XS 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L 16/XL 18/XXL

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$24 $40

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Ivy mini skirt in pinstriped Gramercy suiting - Other

Petite Ivy mini skirt in pinstriped Gramercy suiting

$148

4.4 (14)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

40% OFF

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

$33 $55

4.6 (2803) 3 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$24 $40

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite lace Fairfax skirt - Black

Petite lace Fairfax skirt

$168

4.9 (50) 2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 6/S 10/M 12/L

Petite lace Fairfax skirt - Other

Petite lace Fairfax skirt

$168

4.9 (50) 2 colors

0/XS

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

40% OFF

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

$30 $50

4.6 (2803) 3 colors

0/XS 12/L 14/L 16/XL 18/XXL

work everyday classic

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

40% OFF

SoComfy Oversized Raglan Sweatshirt

$24 $40

4.5 (4026) 7 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

40% OFF

Best Seller

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

$30 $50

4.5 (1414) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 14/L 18/XXL

work everyday classic

Mid-Rise Arc Barrel Jeans

40% OFF

Mid-Rise Arc Barrel Jeans

$30 $50

4.4 (96) 3 colors

12/L 14/L

Long-Sleeve Ruffle-Trim Button-Front Top

40% OFF

New

Long-Sleeve Ruffle-Trim Button-Front Top

$21 $35

4.7 (3) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite mini zip-up shirt-dress in lightweight corduroy - Navy

Petite mini zip-up shirt-dress in lightweight corduroy

$178

4.7 (18) 2 colors

00/XXS 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Petite mini zip-up shirt-dress in lightweight corduroy - Other

Petite mini zip-up shirt-dress in lightweight corduroy

$178

4.7 (18) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

40% OFF

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

$30 $50

4.5 (1414) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 8/M

work everyday date-night

Long-Sleeve Ruffle-Trim Button-Front Top

40% OFF

New

Long-Sleeve Ruffle-Trim Button-Front Top

$21 $35

4.7 (3) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux crocodile leather - Green

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux crocodile leather

$168

4.9 (14)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 6/S 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

40% OFF

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

$30 $50

4.5 (1414) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 8/M

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

40% OFF

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

$30 $50

4.8 (78) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Cozy Crew-Neck Wool-Blend Cardigan

40% OFF

Best Seller

Cozy Crew-Neck Wool-Blend Cardigan

$30 $50

4.6 (287)

0/XS 4/S

Petite pleated prep skirt in striped Gramercy suiting - Other

Petite pleated prep skirt in striped Gramercy suiting

$168

4.9 (7)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

40% OFF

High-Waisted Pull-On Pixie Wide Leg Pants

$30 $50

4.5 (1414) 4 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

40% OFF

Best Seller

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

$30 $50

4.8 (78) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Petite Parc dress in contrast-trim four-season stretch - Other

Petite Parc dress in contrast-trim four-season stretch

$228

4.0 (11)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

40% OFF

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

$27 $45

4.3 (91) 3 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

40% OFF

New

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

$30 $50

4.8 (78) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in pinstriped lightspun wool blend - Other

Petite No. 2 Pencil® skirt in pinstriped lightspun wool blend

$148

4.8 (31)

8/M

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

40% OFF

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

$27 $45

4.3 (91) 3 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

40% OFF

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

$30 $50

4.8 (78) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Petite pleated prep skirt in Gramercy suiting - Black

Petite pleated prep skirt in Gramercy suiting

$168

4.9 (7)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

40% OFF

Mid-Rise Straight Leg Jeans

$27 $45

4.3 (91) 3 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

40% OFF

Water-Resistant Puffer Vest

$30 $50

4.8 (78) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Petite Natasha slip dress in cupro blend - Black

Petite Natasha slip dress in cupro blend

$178

4.8 (27) 2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Petite Natasha slip dress in cupro blend - Other

Petite Natasha slip dress in cupro blend

$178

4.8 (27) 2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Dynamic Fleece Sweatpants

40% OFF

High-Waisted Dynamic Fleece Sweatpants

$27 $45

4.7 (2306)

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

everyday active sporty

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

40% OFF

Best Seller

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

$18 $30

4.6 (7) 3 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

40% OFF

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

$9 $15

4.7 (19466) 7 colors

20/XXL

everyday active classic

Petite Ivy mini skirt in houndstooth Gramercy suiting - Other

Petite Ivy mini skirt in houndstooth Gramercy suiting

$148

4.4 (5)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

40% OFF

Best Seller

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

$27 $45

4.4 (200) 5 colors

0/XS 2/XS 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L 16/XL +1

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

40% OFF

Extra High-Waisted Taylor Wide-Leg Trouser Pants

$30 $50

4.6 (2803) 5 colors

2/XS 4/S 16/XL 18/XXL

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

40% OFF

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

$18 $30

4.6 (7) 3 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Chiara coat in plaid double faced - Other

Petite Chiara coat in plaid double faced

$450

4.0 (1)

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

40% OFF

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

$27 $45

4.4 (200) 5 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

40% OFF

Lapel Collar Short-Sleeve Button-Front Top

$18 $30

4.6 (7) 3 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux leather - Black

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux leather

$148

4.9 (14) 2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux leather - Other

Petite Fairfax skirt in faux leather

$148

4.9 (14) 2 colors

00/XXS 0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

40% OFF

High-Waisted Flare Jeans

$27 $45

4.4 (200) 5 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L +2

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

40% OFF

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

$9 $15

4.7 (19466) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

everyday active classic

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

40% OFF

Best Seller

Crop Ribbed Tank Top

$9 $15

4.7 (19466) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M

everyday active vacation

«
1
…
6
7
8
9
10
…
27
»

Frequently Asked Questions

Does J.Crew or Old Navy have more petite items?: Old Navy currently has more, with 1,675 petite items versus 257.
Which is cheaper on average, J.Crew or Old Navy?: Average current prices are $176 at J.Crew and $20 at Old Navy.
Which retailer has more petite items on sale?: J.Crew has 9% of its petite items on sale, versus 100% at Old Navy.
What sizes do J.Crew and Old Navy carry in petite?: Both retailers offer petite sizing roughly from 00/XXS to 20/XXL depending on the item.
How often is this comparison updated?: Counts and prices on this page are recomputed from the live catalog on each request; the underlying catalog refreshes daily.