Macy's vs Old Navy Petite | Petite Pick

As of the latest catalog refresh, Petite Pick indexes 2,737 petite items at Macy's and 1,675 at Old Navy. Average current price is $77 at Macy's versus $20 at Old Navy; 67% of Macy's petite items are on sale versus 100% at Old Navy.

Macy's carries 2,737 petite items across 11 categories (top: Tops (857), Dresses (587), Sweaters (403)). Old Navy carries 1,675 across 9 categories (top: Tops (536), Activewear (404), Sweaters (241)). Average current prices are $77 and $20 respectively.

Retailers on this page

Retailer	Items	Avg price	From	On sale
Nordstrom	3,179	$190	$17	36%
Macy's	2,737	$77	$5	67%
Old Navy	1,675	$20	$3	100%
ASOS	1,443	$75	$12	29%
Talbots	1,302	$109	$30	0%

Macy's vs Old Navy Petite — Side-by-Side Comparison (4,412)

Women's and Petite Low Rise Pleated Wide Leg Pants - Seasalt Multi

Women's and Petite Low Rise Pleated Wide Leg Pants

$125

0/XS

Petite Asymmetric-Neck Side-Slit Gown - Plum

Petite Asymmetric-Neck Side-Slit Gown

$249

4.5 (47) 2 colors

6/S

date-night going-out wedding-guest

Petite Pinstripe Long-Sleeve V-Neck Blouse - Jones Black/Natural White

Petite Pinstripe Long-Sleeve V-Neck Blouse

$90

0/XS

Dynamic Fleece Oversized Cropped Sweatshirt

50% OFF

Dynamic Fleece Oversized Cropped Sweatshirt

$20 $40

4.5 (43)

16/XL

Petite Full-Zip Mock Neck Basket-Weave Knit Jacket - Cafe Au Lait

Petite Full-Zip Mock Neck Basket-Weave Knit Jacket

$100

0/XS

Petite Glitter Galaxy One-Shoulder Ruched Gown - Brown

Petite Glitter Galaxy One-Shoulder Ruched Gown

$279

4.3 (7)

6/S

30% OFF

Petite Manhattan Logo Graphic Crewneck Short-Sleeve T-Shirt

$34 $49

0/XS

Petite Geometric-Print Long-Sleeve Collared Blouse - Jones Black/Cafe Au Lait

Petite Geometric-Print Long-Sleeve Collared Blouse

$70

0/XS

Petite Feather Trim Sheath Long-Sleeve Mock-Neck Midi Dress - Anne Black

30% OFF

Petite Feather Trim Sheath Long-Sleeve Mock-Neck Midi Dress

$98 $140

6/S

Petite Sequin Sheer Peplum Blouse - Black

Petite Sequin Sheer Peplum Blouse

$98

0/XS

Petite Metallic Print Fit & Flare Dress - Black/Gold

Petite Metallic Print Fit & Flare Dress

$79

4.4 (27)

6/S

StudioSmooth Base Layer Tank Top

60% OFF

StudioSmooth Base Layer Tank Top

$9 $23

4.6 (252)

16/XL

Petite Fitted Cuffed-Roll Short-Sleeve Crewneck Pullover Sweater - Light Antelope Heather

Petite Fitted Cuffed-Roll Short-Sleeve Crewneck Pullover Sweater

$80

0/XS

Petite Tie-Neck Button-Down Satin Long-Sleeve Blouse - Black/Cranberry

30% OFF

Petite Tie-Neck Button-Down Satin Long-Sleeve Blouse

$69 $99

0/XS

Petite One Button Blazer Blazer - Black

Petite One Button Blazer Blazer

$189

3.5 (2)

6/S

work everyday date-night

Petite Ruched 3/4-Sleeve Gown - Black

Petite Ruched 3/4-Sleeve Gown

$139

4.2 (29)

6/S

work date-night going-out

Fitted Bell-Sleeve Ruffle Top

60% OFF

Fitted Bell-Sleeve Ruffle Top

$13 $33

4.9 (47)

16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Shine Perfect Short-Sleeve Crewneck Metallic T-Shirt - Liquid Silver

Petite Shine Perfect Short-Sleeve Crewneck Metallic T-Shirt

$49

0/XS

Petite Tulip-Sleeve Jewel Neck Sheath Dress - Malachite

60% OFF

Petite Tulip-Sleeve Jewel Neck Sheath Dress

$40 $100

4.0 (4)

6/S

Off-The-Shoulder Fitted Top

50% OFF

Off-The-Shoulder Fitted Top

$10 $20

3.4 (17) 3 colors

16/XL 20/XXL

Women's Petite Ribbed Sleeveless Tank Sweater - Iron

65% OFF

Women's Petite Ribbed Sleeveless Tank Sweater

$30 $85

1.0 (1) 2 colors

0/XS

Petite Logo Crewneck Long-Sleeve Graphic-Print Sweatshirt

$109

0/XS

Stretch Cotton Boatneck T-Shirt - Dark Garnet

Stretch Cotton Boatneck T-Shirt

$55

4.5 (354) 3 colors

0/XS

Petite Notch Collar Three-Button Front Jacket - Jones Khaki

70% OFF

Petite Notch Collar Three-Button Front Jacket

$36 $120

3.0 (1)

6/S

Petite Relay Velvet Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants - Black

Petite Relay Velvet Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants

$99

0/XS

Petite Beaded Embellished V Neck Cap Sleeve Column Gown - Chocolate

Petite Beaded Embellished V Neck Cap Sleeve Column Gown

$698

2 colors

0/XS

Eileen Fisher Petite Pucker Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants - Gold Print

Eileen Fisher Petite Pucker Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants

$188

4.5 (40)

0/XS

Petite Roll Tab Sleeve Blouse with Pockets - Oxford Tan

50% OFF

Petite Roll Tab Sleeve Blouse with Pockets

$22 $44

1.0 (1)

6/S

work everyday vacation

Petite Pleated Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants - Heathered Navy

Petite Pleated Wide-Leg Pull-On Pants

$109

0/XS

Petite V-Neck A-Line Gown - Navy

Petite V-Neck A-Line Gown

$249

4.1 (9)

6/S

Cap-Sleeve Tie-Back Top

60% OFF

Cap-Sleeve Tie-Back Top

$10 $25

4.7 (546)

16/XL 20/XXL

everyday date-night going-out

Petite Rhinestone Taxi Photoreal T-Shirt - White/Taxi Cab Yellow

30% OFF

Petite Rhinestone Taxi Photoreal T-Shirt

$34 $49

4.8 (4)

0/XS

everyday modern streetwear

Petite Smocked-Waist Long-Sleeve V-Neck Dress - Blue Lagoon

Petite Smocked-Waist Long-Sleeve V-Neck Dress

$129

5.0 (2)

6/S

Petite Boat Neck Soft Scuba Pullover Sweater - Black

Petite Boat Neck Soft Scuba Pullover Sweater

$80

0/XS

Petite A-Line Midi Turtleneck Dress - Brunette/charcoal

Petite A-Line Midi Turtleneck Dress

$99

5.0 (3)

6/S

Maternity Empire Waist Nursing Midi Tea Dress in TENCEL - Black

Maternity Empire Waist Nursing Midi Tea Dress in TENCEL

$229

4.0 (3)

0/XS

Petite Extended Shoulder V-Neck Short-Sleeve Blouse - Cafe Au Lait

Petite Extended Shoulder V-Neck Short-Sleeve Blouse

$70

2 colors

0/XS

Petite Printed Side Tab Floral A-Line 3/4-Sleeve Midi Dress - Green/black

Petite Printed Side Tab Floral A-Line 3/4-Sleeve Midi Dress

$89

3.8 (4)

6/S

Petite V-Neck Floral-Print Long-Sleeve Blouse - Blue Stone

Petite V-Neck Floral-Print Long-Sleeve Blouse

$80

0/XS

Petite 3/4-Sleeve Collared Zip-Front Jacket - Pecan

40% OFF

Petite 3/4-Sleeve Collared Zip-Front Jacket

$60 $100

6/S

Petite Crew Neck Short-Sleeve T-Shirt - Black

Petite Crew Neck Short-Sleeve T-Shirt

$59

3.5 (2)

0/XS

Petite Embroidered A-Line Bell Sleeve Dress - Black

Petite Embroidered A-Line Bell Sleeve Dress

$99

4.0 (1) 2 colors

6/S

SoSoft Cotton Tie-Front Pointelle Tank Top

50% OFF

SoSoft Cotton Tie-Front Pointelle Tank Top

$18 $37

4.8 (12) 4 colors

16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Mode Sequin-Embellished 3/4-Sleeve T-Shirt - Black

Petite Mode Sequin-Embellished 3/4-Sleeve T-Shirt

$79

0/XS

Women's One-Button Notch-Collar Jacket & Fly-Front Slim Pants Suit - Dark Azalea

48% OFF

Women's One-Button Notch-Collar Jacket & Fly-Front Slim Pants Suit

$120 $235

4.9 (12) 3 colors

6/S

Petite Flutter Sleeve Lace Top - White

50% OFF

Petite Flutter Sleeve Lace Top

$21 $42

6/S

everyday work date-night

Petite Lace Jacket and Ball Gown, 2-Piece Set - Deep Plum

Petite Lace Jacket and Ball Gown, 2-Piece Set

$249

4.2 (6)

6/S

Petite Puff Sleeve Scoop Neck Top - Pink Multi Floral

Petite Puff Sleeve Scoop Neck Top

$59

3.0 (2)

0/XS

everyday vacation classic

Petite Sleeveless Polo Top - White

40% OFF

Petite Sleeveless Polo Top

$29 $49

5.0 (4) 3 colors

6/S

everyday work active

Petite Twist-Knot V-Neck Short-Sleeve Sweater - Medium Heather Grey

Petite Twist-Knot V-Neck Short-Sleeve Sweater

$110

0/XS

Sunday Sleep Knit Jersey Pant Set

40% OFF

Sunday Sleep Knit Jersey Pant Set

$30 $50

4.7 (159) 3 colors

16/XL 20/XXL

Petite Side Ruched High Neck Long Sleeve Top With Rhinestud Logo

$69

2.7 (3) 2 colors

0/XS

everyday date-night going-out

Petite Polished Satin Wide-Leg Pull-On Track Pants - Black

Petite Polished Satin Wide-Leg Pull-On Track Pants

$99

0/XS

Petite Long-Sleeve Button-Front Paisley-Print Satin Twill Blouse - Blue Stone

Petite Long-Sleeve Button-Front Paisley-Print Satin Twill Blouse

$100

0/XS

Petite Velvet Bell-Sleeve Mesh-Trim Dress - Hunter

Petite Velvet Bell-Sleeve Mesh-Trim Dress

$159

4.2 (6)

6/S

Shane Pant - Everyday Twill - Night

$279

0/XS

Petite Tie-Neck Mock Neck Long-Sleeve Sweater - Medium Heather Grey

Petite Tie-Neck Mock Neck Long-Sleeve Sweater

$120

0/XS

Petite Pleat Neck Sleeveless Top - White

30% OFF

Petite Pleat Neck Sleeveless Top

$34 $49

4.7 (120)

6/S

work everyday date-night

Petite Cut Sew Sleeveless Crewneck Embellished Blouse - Soft White

Petite Cut Sew Sleeveless Crewneck Embellished Blouse

$79

0/XS

Straight Full-Length Pants - Black

Straight Full-Length Pants

$89

4.4 (44)

6/S

Petite Pointelle Short-Sleeve Crewneck Sweater - Heather Hazelnut

Petite Pointelle Short-Sleeve Crewneck Sweater

$99

0/XS

Exhale Seamless Fitted Rib Tank

50% OFF

Exhale Seamless Fitted Rib Tank

$10 $20

4.7 (1754) 3 colors

0/XS 16/XL

active everyday sporty

Petite Cozy Long Sleeves Sweatshirt - Frost Blue/Clear Silver

Petite Cozy Long Sleeves Sweatshirt

$69

4.7 (10) 3 colors

0/XS

Petite V-Neck Long-Sleeve A-Line Gown - Wine Gold

Petite V-Neck Long-Sleeve A-Line Gown

$320

4.4 (23)

6/S

wedding-guest date-night going-out

Petite Perfect Sequin Crewneck Short-Sleeve Sweater - Black

Petite Perfect Sequin Crewneck Short-Sleeve Sweater

$89

0/XS

Petite Asymmetrical One-Shoulder Ruffle Gown Dress - Burgundy

Petite Asymmetrical One-Shoulder Ruffle Gown Dress

$269

3.5 (4)

6/S

Petite Crystal-Embellished Collared Short-Sleeve Blouse - Black

Petite Crystal-Embellished Collared Short-Sleeve Blouse

$99

0/XS

Petite Embroidered Sweetheart Ball Gown - Cornflower

60% OFF

Petite Embroidered Sweetheart Ball Gown

$116 $289

4.2 (5)

6/S

wedding-guest date-night going-out

Petite V-Neck Pull-On Bubble Top - Chambray with White

Petite V-Neck Pull-On Bubble Top

$89

3.7 (3)

0/XS

everyday vacation modern

Petite Chevron-Trimmed Cowl-Neck Sweater - Cabernet red

46% OFF

Petite Chevron-Trimmed Cowl-Neck Sweater

$25 $46

3.0 (3) 5 colors

6/S

Women's Cotton 3/4-Sleeve Henley Top - Frozen Blue

50% OFF

Women's Cotton 3/4-Sleeve Henley Top

$10 $20

4.4 (1083) 5 colors

0/XS

Petite Long Fit & Flare Sequins Scoop Neck Lace Dress and Jacket, 2-Piece Set - Eggplant

Petite Long Fit & Flare Sequins Scoop Neck Lace Dress and Jacket, 2-Piece Set

$179

4.3 (4) 3 colors

6/S

«
1
…
49
50
51
52
53
…
62
»

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Macy's or Old Navy have more petite items?: Macy's currently has more, with 2,737 petite items versus 1,675.
Which is cheaper on average, Macy's or Old Navy?: Average current prices are $77 at Macy's and $20 at Old Navy.
Which retailer has more petite items on sale?: Macy's has 67% of its petite items on sale, versus 100% at Old Navy.
What sizes do Macy's and Old Navy carry in petite?: Both retailers offer petite sizing roughly from 00/XXS to 20/XXL depending on the item.
How often is this comparison updated?: Counts and prices on this page are recomputed from the live catalog on each request; the underlying catalog refreshes daily.