$
–
$
On Sale Biggest Discounts Top Rated New Arrivals
Athleta Old Navy Clear all

As of the latest catalog refresh, Petite Pick indexes 479 petite items at Athleta and 1,675 at Old Navy. Average current price is $81 at Athleta versus $20 at Old Navy; 66% of Athleta petite items are on sale versus 100% at Old Navy.

Athleta carries 479 petite items across 6 categories (top: Pants (279), Jackets (102), Tops (46)). Old Navy carries 1,675 across 9 categories (top: Tops (536), Activewear (404), Sweaters (241)). Average current prices are $81 and $20 respectively.

Retailers on this page

Retailer Items Avg price From On sale
Nordstrom 3,179 $190 $17 36%
Macy's 2,737 $77 $5 67%
Old Navy 1,675 $20 $3 100%
ASOS 1,443 $75 $12 29%
Talbots 1,302 $109 $30 0%

Athleta vs Old Navy Petite — Side-by-Side Comparison (2,154)

Long-Sleeve Oversized Turtleneck Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Oversized Turtleneck Top
$16 $27
4.4 (118) 6 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
$21 $35
4.7 (32) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
$21 $35
4.7 (32) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
$21 $35
4.7 (32) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Oversized Mock-Neck Long-Sleeve Top
$21 $35
4.7 (32) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Signature Rib Apron Dress
74% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Signature Rib Apron Dress
$25 $99
4.2 (16) 2 colors
12/L 14/L
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fitted Performance Fleece Full-Zip Jacket
$18 $30
4.6 (144) 7 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
SoSoft Cropped Long-Sleeve Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Cropped Long-Sleeve Sweater
$30 $50
4.7 (90)
8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Transcend Dress
71% OFF
Athleta
Transcend Dress
$33 $115
4.6 (524)
12/L 14/L
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
$15 $25
4.2 (26) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
60% OFF
Old Navy
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
$10 $25
4.2 (26) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
$15 $25
4.2 (26) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudMotion Long-Sleeve Tunic
$15 $25
4.2 (26) 4 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Best Seller
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
40% OFF
Best Seller
Old Navy
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
$24 $40
4.6 (45) 3 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
$24 $40
4.6 (45) 3 colors
8/M 12/L 16/XL
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
StudioSmooth Long-Sleeve Wrap Top
$24 $40
4.6 (45) 3 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
Fluid Seamless Fitted Top
$18 $30
4.7 (2453) 6 colors
0/XS 16/XL
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$15 $25
4.3 (61) 5 colors
0/XS 12/L 16/XL
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
60% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$10 $25
4.3 (61) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
High-Waisted Linen-Blend Super Wide-Leg Pants
60% OFF
Linen
Old Navy
High-Waisted Linen-Blend Super Wide-Leg Pants
$16 $40
4.5 (4083)
0/XS 2/XS
everyday vacation bohemian
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$15 $25
4.3 (61) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 12/L 16/XL
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$15 $25
4.3 (61) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
40% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$15 $25
4.3 (61) 5 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
60% OFF
Old Navy
CloudLite Ribbed Long-Sleeve Boatneck Top
$10 $25
4.3 (61) 6 colors
0/XS
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Best Seller
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Crossroads Dress
50% OFF
New In Best Seller
Athleta
Crossroads Dress
$78 $155
3.5 (2)
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Best Seller
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Journey Dress
30% OFF
Athleta
Journey Dress
$76 $109
4.7 (232) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Best Seller
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Journey Dress
30% OFF
Athleta
Journey Dress
$76 $109
4.7 (232) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Signature Rib Long Sleeve Maxi Dress
40% OFF
Athleta
Signature Rib Long Sleeve Maxi Dress
$69 $115
4.6 (5) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Signature Rib Long Sleeve Maxi Dress
40% OFF
Athleta
Signature Rib Long Sleeve Maxi Dress
$69 $115
4.6 (5) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Seasoft Tee Dress
54% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Seasoft Tee Dress
$45 $99
4.7 (140) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Seasoft Tee Dress
54% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Seasoft Tee Dress
$45 $99
4.7 (140) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
40% OFF
Old Navy
Long-Sleeve Crew-Neck Henley T-Shirt
$20 $33
4.8 (388) 8 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Transcend Scoop Dress
62% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Transcend Scoop Dress
$45 $119
4.6 (179) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
Seasoft Tee Dress
24% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Seasoft Tee Dress
$75 $99
4.7 (140) 4 colors
4/S 6/S
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Transcend Scoop Dress
53% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Transcend Scoop Dress
$55 $119
4.6 (179) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Featherweight Plissé Dress
74% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Featherweight Plissé Dress
$35 $135
3.2 (29)
0/XS 2/XS 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Wishful Cotton Dress
66% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Wishful Cotton Dress
$30 $89
3.5 (4) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Wishful Cotton Dress
66% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Wishful Cotton Dress
$30 $89
3.5 (4) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Wishful Cotton Dress
55% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Wishful Cotton Dress
$40 $89
3.5 (4) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
40% OFF
Athleta
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
$59 $99
4.8 (1081) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
40% OFF
Athleta
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
$59 $99
4.8 (1081) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
39% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Signature Rib Maxi Dress
$60 $99
4.8 (1081) 3 colors
0/XS 2/XS 12/L 14/L
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
40% OFF
Old Navy
SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater
$18 $30
4.8 (294) 9 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Tee Time Dress
24% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Tee Time Dress
$120 $159
4.2 (43) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 12/L 14/L
Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top
55% OFF
100% Cotton
Old Navy
Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top
$16 $37
4.6 (112) 3 colors
0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL
Tee Time Dress
40% OFF
Just Reduced
Athleta
Tee Time Dress
$95 $159
4.2 (43) 2 colors
0/XS 2/XS 12/L 14/L

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Athleta or Old Navy have more petite items?
Old Navy currently has more, with 1,675 petite items versus 479.
Which is cheaper on average, Athleta or Old Navy?
Average current prices are $81 at Athleta and $20 at Old Navy.
Which retailer has more petite items on sale?
Athleta has 66% of its petite items on sale, versus 100% at Old Navy.
What sizes do Athleta and Old Navy carry in petite?
Both retailers offer petite sizing roughly from 00/XXS to 20/XXL depending on the item.
How often is this comparison updated?
Counts and prices on this page are recomputed from the live catalog on each request; the underlying catalog refreshes daily.