Athleta vs Old Navy Petite | Petite Pick

As of the latest catalog refresh, Petite Pick indexes 479 petite items at Athleta and 1,675 at Old Navy. Average current price is $81 at Athleta versus $20 at Old Navy; 66% of Athleta petite items are on sale versus 100% at Old Navy.

Athleta carries 479 petite items across 6 categories (top: Pants (279), Jackets (102), Tops (46)). Old Navy carries 1,675 across 9 categories (top: Tops (536), Activewear (404), Sweaters (241)). Average current prices are $81 and $20 respectively.

Retailers on this page

Retailer	Items	Avg price	From	On sale
Nordstrom	3,179	$190	$17	36%
Macy's	2,737	$77	$5	67%
Old Navy	1,675	$20	$3	100%
ASOS	1,443	$75	$12	29%
Talbots	1,302	$109	$30	0%

Athleta vs Old Navy Petite — Side-by-Side Comparison (2,154)

High-Waisted Cotton Biker Shorts -- 6-inch inseam

40% OFF

High-Waisted Cotton Biker Shorts -- 6-inch inseam

$8 $13

4.7 (4276)

16/XL 18/XXL 20/XXL

active everyday sporty

Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top

50% OFF

100% Cotton

Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top

$18 $37

4.6 (112) 3 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater

40% OFF

SoSoft Lite Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Ribbed Sweater

$18 $30

4.8 (294) 10 colors

16/XL 20/XXL

Signature Rib Apron Dress

74% OFF

Just Reduced

Signature Rib Apron Dress

$25 $99

4.2 (16)

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 12/L 14/L

Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top

50% OFF

100% Cotton

Seaside Cotton Pointelle Peplum Tank Top

$18 $37

4.6 (112) 3 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Signature Rib Tee Dress

66% OFF

Just Reduced

Signature Rib Tee Dress

$30 $89

4.6 (510) 2 colors

0/XS 2/XS 4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Signature Rib Tee Dress

21% OFF

Signature Rib Tee Dress

$70 $89

4.6 (510) 2 colors

0/XS 2/XS

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Transcend Dress

73% OFF

Transcend Dress

$30 $115

4.6 (524)

0/XS 2/XS 8/M 10/M

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Essential Tee Dress

68% OFF

Essential Tee Dress

$25 $79

4.6 (1868)

0/XS 2/XS

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 14 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 20/XXL

Salutation Jacket

30% OFF

Top Gift

Salutation Jacket

$90 $129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Salutation Jacket

Top Gift

Salutation Jacket

$129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS 8/M 12/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL

Salutation Jacket

Top Gift

Salutation Jacket

$129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S

High-Waisted PowerChill Fold-Over Bootcut Leggings

40% OFF

Matching Sets

High-Waisted PowerChill Fold-Over Bootcut Leggings

$21 $35

4.6 (1091) 4 colors

16/XL 18/XXL

active everyday sporty

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Salutation Jacket

Top Gift

Salutation Jacket

$129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Salutation Jacket

22% OFF

New to Sale

Salutation Jacket

$100 $129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

60% OFF

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

$12 $30

4.7 (4176) 7 colors

20/XXL

Salutation Jacket

Top Gift

Salutation Jacket

$129

4.8 (4420) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Salutation Jacket 2.0

64% OFF

Salutation Jacket 2.0

$46 $129

4.7 (1173)

0/XS

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

60% OFF

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

$14 $35

4.7 (4176) 7 colors

20/XXL

Salutation Crop Jacket

Salutation Crop Jacket

$119

4.7 (857) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 12/L

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

75% OFF

Cropped Button-Down Striped Shirt

$10 $40

4.7 (4176) 7 colors

20/XXL

Salutation Crop Jacket

Salutation Crop Jacket

$119

4.7 (857) 2 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

40% OFF

Fitted Waffle-Knit Cropped T-Shirt

$9 $15

4.6 (202) 13 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Coat

29% OFF

New In

In the Clouds Coat

$174 $249

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Jacket

30% OFF

Top Gift New In

In the Clouds Jacket

$104 $149

4.4 (7) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

RainOut Roam Jacket

40% OFF

New Silhouette

RainOut Roam Jacket

$179 $299

3.1 (14) 2 colors

4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Jacket

30% OFF

Top Gift

In the Clouds Jacket

$104 $149

4.4 (7) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

RainOut Roam Jacket

40% OFF

New Silhouette

RainOut Roam Jacket

$179 $299

3.1 (14) 2 colors

4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Jacket

30% OFF

Top Gift Best Seller

In the Clouds Jacket

$104 $149

4.4 (7) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Best Seller

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 8 colors

16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Jacket

30% OFF

Top Gift Best Seller

In the Clouds Jacket

$104 $149

4.4 (7) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

30% OFF

Best Seller

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

$76 $109

3.1 (24) 8 colors

4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Jacket

Top Gift

In the Clouds Jacket

$149

4.4 (7) 5 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Best Seller

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 6 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Vest

40% OFF

New Silhouette

In the Clouds Vest

$77 $129

3.2 (5) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Vest

40% OFF

New Silhouette

In the Clouds Vest

$77 $129

3.2 (5) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

40% OFF

Heavyweight Crew-Neck T-Shirt

$14 $23

4.7 (317) 8 colors

0/XS 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Vest

40% OFF

New In

In the Clouds Vest

$77 $129

3.2 (5) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

30% OFF

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

$76 $109

3.1 (24) 8 colors

4/S 12/L

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

80% OFF

Matching Sets

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

$10 $50

4.5 (222) 4 colors

4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L 16/XL 18/XXL

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

In the Clouds Vest

New Silhouette

In the Clouds Vest

$129

3.2 (5) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Coastline Jacket

40% OFF

New Silhouette Top Gift

Coastline Jacket

$113 $189

3.8 (8) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

30% OFF

Forever Fleece Classic Full Zip Sweatshirt

$76 $109

3.1 (24) 8 colors

4/S 8/M 12/L

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

75% OFF

Matching Sets

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

$12 $50

4.5 (222) 4 colors

4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Coastline Jacket

40% OFF

New Collection Top Gift

Coastline Jacket

$113 $189

3.8 (8) 4 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L

Form Knit Bomber Sweatshirt

Best Seller

Form Knit Bomber Sweatshirt

$129

3.8 (10) 3 colors

12/L

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

70% OFF

Matching Sets

Bounce Fleece Short-Sleeve Polo Dress

$15 $50

4.5 (222) 4 colors

4/S 6/S 8/M 10/M 12/L 14/L 16/XL 18/XXL

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

40% OFF

Hug Double-Layer Crew-Neck Long-Sleeve Top

$14 $23

4.6 (192) 8 colors

0/XS 4/S 8/M 12/L 16/XL 20/XXL

Coastline Jacket

29% OFF

Top Gift New In

Coastline Jacket

$132 $189

3.8 (8) 4 colors

0/XS 12/L

«
1
…
18
19
20
21
22
…
30
»

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Athleta or Old Navy have more petite items?: Old Navy currently has more, with 1,675 petite items versus 479.
Which is cheaper on average, Athleta or Old Navy?: Average current prices are $81 at Athleta and $20 at Old Navy.
Which retailer has more petite items on sale?: Athleta has 66% of its petite items on sale, versus 100% at Old Navy.
What sizes do Athleta and Old Navy carry in petite?: Both retailers offer petite sizing roughly from 00/XXS to 20/XXL depending on the item.
How often is this comparison updated?: Counts and prices on this page are recomputed from the live catalog on each request; the underlying catalog refreshes daily.